| Making
it Hot for Snow and Ice
Highway crews see a “beautiful” mid-winter
snowfall a little bit differently than the average person. To children
it might mean a day off from school. To skiers it could mean a great
day on the slopes. To office workers it might mean a rough drive
to work. But, to highway folks it means work!
First, there is information to be gathered. When will the
storm get here? How much snowfall is expected? How long will
it last? And, during the storm, information is needed on the current
road conditions.
People expect their roads to be plowed. There are trucks
to fill with salt, drivers to round up, and plow routes to be driven.
The planning for all this begins months earlier, long before the snow starts
to fall. Purchasing and stock-
piling salt, equipment maintenance, and personnel training are all
part of the annual routine of getting ready for winter.
Planning Decisions
Early in the planning process there are a number
of important decisions to be made:
¨ What kind of truck will you use, outfitted with a front-end plow,
or under-body plow?
¨ What kind of spreader will you use?¨ How many plows do you
need?
¨ How will you organize plowing routes to be efficient and effective?
¨ What level of service should you provide?
¨ Where are the high priority roads?
¨ When will you use abrasives and when straight salt?
¨ Will you add some calcium chloride, in liquid or solid form,
and under what circumstances?
Operational Decisions
In addition to planning decisions, there are operational decisions
to be made after you learn that a storm is coming. One of them is
how you will “handle” the storm. Some might say that the storm handles
you, you do not handle it. But in fact, you can decide whether you
will be proactive or reactive. Over the years most local highway
agencies have been reactive. That is, they wait until the snow starts
to accumulate, and then they go to work to remove it. The public
has come to expect this approach.
Proactive Approach
A growing number of local highway agencies are adopting the proactive
approach. They get out shortly before the storm arrives, and try
to stay ahead of it. In doing so they find they can provide a higher
level of service, use less chemicals and maybe even save money, in the
process.
To be successful with this approach you need to hone your management
skills. You must have a good understanding of the materials and equipment
you are using. And, you need to tailor your attack for the several
different types of storms that may occur.
Deicing vs. Anti-icing
The reactive approach uses deicing, while the proactive approach
uses anti-icing. With the reactive approach snow often packs into
ice. It bonds to the pavement due to traffic on the road. Plows
cannot easily break this bond, so chemicals are used to deice the road
surface. The overall objective of anti-icing is to prevent the ice
from ever forming a bond with the pavement. Anti-icing involves strategically
placing small amounts of chemicals on the road ahead of the storm, and
during the storm, to deter the bonding of the ice.
Understanding How Salt Works
Do you understand why road salt (sodium chloride) and related
chemicals are able to melt ice? Whether you are doing deicing or
anti-icing, it is vitally important to know about the limitations of the
materials you are using and how they work.
Everyone knows that water freezes at 32°F. But this
is true only for pure water. In order for water to freeze, heat has
to be removed from it. In order to melt the ice, the same amount
of heat has to be put back in. The amount of heat needed to change
ice into water could raise the temperature of the water from 32°F to
108°F.
That is a lot of heat, and it mainly comes from the air.
If the air temperature over a road is close to 32°F it takes a long
time to transfer the necessary heat. If the sun is out, the radiant
heat from the sun supplements the limited amount of heat in the cool air.
The melting process speeds up. Warm air, combined with the wind and
a sunny day, will melt snow and ice fairly quickly.
In late fall the materials beneath the road will be above 32°F,
and they can contribute some heat to help melt the ice. But in mid-winter
the materials under the road will be frozen to a considerable depth, thus
eliminating this source of heat.
When salt is added to water it dissolves to form a brine.
This lowers the freezing/melting temperature. Thus when salt is placed
on ice it has the same effect as if the air were warmer. The graph
shows that as the salt concentration goes from zero to 23 percent, the
freezing temperature steadily goes down to minus 6°F. This is
called freezing point depression. At temperatures below the freezing
line but about -6°F, and at salt concentrations less that 23 percent,
a viscous slush is formed. It consists of a mixture of ice crystals
and brine. The mixture will freeze solid at -6°F regardless of
the salt concentration.
The concentration is the amount of salt in the solution.
For instance, a ten percent brine would have 10 pounds of salt for every
90 pounds of water, making 100 pounds of solution. At concentrations
greater than 23 percent the brine is saturated with salt, and any additional
salt remains in crystalline form. If water or ice is added to this
mix the excess salt goes into solution to keep the brine at 23 percent
concentration and the freezing point at -6°F.
Freezing point depression is the reason why salt melts the compacted
snow (i.e., ice) on the road. If the air temperature is above -6°F,
when salt is spread on the road it causes ice to melt, forming a small
amount of brine at 23 percent concentration around the salt crystal.
Additional salt is used to make more brine. This process continues
until either the salt is used up or the ice is all melted.
With some help from vehicle tires, the brine is mixed with the
compacted snow. If the ice is bonded to the pavement it can take
a lot of salt to loosen the bond. The plow comes along and pushes
the slush aside, additional salt is spread, and the cycle continues until
the end of the storm.
Even though the air temperature is below 32°F, the ice is
melted. In fact, the salt makes it “hot” for the snow and ice!
But as the air temperature gets close to -6°F the effectiveness of the salt diminishes. When the air
temperature gets close to zero, abrasives can be used to enhance traction,
or calcium chloride (which depresses the freezing point down to -60°F)
can be mixed into the salt or used alone. You need to decide beforehand
on the approach you will take for each set of circumstances, and train
your crew accordingly.
Anti-icing is a management strategy that places a small amount
of chemical on the road surface, either as a liquid brine or in solid form,
before the storm begins. A new booklet, Manual of Practice for an
Effective Anti-icing Program, published by the Federal Highway Administration,
describes the recommended strategies.
Written by
Lynne H. Irwin, Director, Cornell Roads Program
Reprinted with permission from
“Nuggets and Nibbles,” Fall 1997
Top
|